Question 1Multiple choiceCellular respiration
A researcher isolates mitochondria from liver cells and suspends them in a solution containing pyruvate, ADP, inorganic phosphate and dissolved oxygen, then measures the rates of oxygen consumption and ATP production. She adds a chemical that lets hydrogen ions () diffuse freely across the inner mitochondrial membrane without passing through ATP synthase. Compared with the untreated mitochondria, which outcome is most likely?
- A.
Oxygen continues to be consumed, but ATP production falls sharply and the energy released by electron transport is lost as heat.
- B.
Oxygen consumption stops, because the electron transport chain cannot operate without a proton gradient to drive it.
- C.
ATP production increases, because hydrogen ions can now reach the matrix more easily.
- D.
and accumulate and the Krebs cycle stops, because electrons can no longer be passed to oxygen.
Worked solution
Separate the two jobs of the inner mitochondrial membrane, because the whole question rests on their being separate. The electron transport chain (ETC), embedded in the cristae, takes the high-energy electrons carried by and , passes them along a series of carriers to oxygen (the final electron acceptor, which is reduced to water) and uses the energy released to pump from the matrix into the intermembrane space. That builds a proton gradient. ATP synthase then lets those protons flow back into the matrix and uses the flow to join ADP and inorganic phosphate; this is chemiosmosis, and it supplies the great majority of the roughly 30–32 ATP made per glucose (older textbooks say 36–38). The two processes are coupled only because the membrane is otherwise impermeable to : the one way back is through ATP synthase.
The added chemical gives protons a second way back, so the gradient drains away without turning ATP synthase. Electrons still flow to oxygen, so oxygen is still consumed; in practice consumption rises, because the ETC runs faster once it is no longer pumping against a steep gradient. The energy that would have been captured in ATP is released as heat. Such chemicals are called uncouplers. 2,4-dinitrophenol was once sold (dangerously) as a diet drug, and a natural uncoupling protein in brown fat warms newborn babies and hibernating mammals by exactly this mechanism.
Option B is the classic trap: it reverses cause and effect. The ETC builds the gradient; the gradient does not drive the ETC. Option C assumes that any proton entering the matrix makes ATP, but only protons passing through ATP synthase do; a leak bypasses the enzyme. Option D describes an ETC inhibitor such as cyanide, which blocks electron flow so that cannot be re-oxidized to and the Krebs cycle backs up. Here electron flow continues, so is regenerated normally and the Krebs cycle keeps running.
Oxygen is still consumed, but ATP production falls sharply and the energy is lost as heat (option A).