Question 1Multiple choiceMicrobial genetics & gene transfer
A streptomycin-sensitive donor strain of Escherichia coli carries a plasmid with a tetracycline-resistance gene; a recipient strain is tetracycline-sensitive but streptomycin-resistant. A student performs three experiments, each time selecting on agar containing both antibiotics so that only recipient cells that have acquired tetracycline resistance can grow.
- The two strains are mixed in broth for 2 h: many doubly resistant colonies appear.
- The strains are grown on opposite sides of a membrane filter whose pores let medium, free DNA and phage particles pass but block bacterial cells: no doubly resistant colonies appear.
- The strains are mixed in broth containing DNase, an enzyme that degrades free DNA: the number of doubly resistant colonies is the same as in experiment 1.
Which mechanism of gene transfer best explains these results?
- A.
Conjugation
- B.
Transformation
- C.
Generalized transduction
- D.
Transposition within the recipient genome
Worked solution
Each experiment is designed to rule mechanisms in or out, so work through them in turn.
Experiment 1 shows that genetic transfer happens between living cells in a mixed culture, which is consistent with conjugation, transformation or transduction.
Experiment 2 is the decisive one. The filter blocks cells but not DNA or phage. If transfer were by transformation (uptake of naked DNA from the medium) or by transduction (delivery of DNA inside a bacteriophage), the DNA or the phage would cross the filter and recipients would still become resistant. No transfer when the cells cannot touch means the mechanism requires direct cell-to-cell contact, which is the defining feature of conjugation: a sex pilus draws donor and recipient together, a mating bridge forms, and a single strand of the plasmid is passed across and copied in the recipient.
Experiment 3 confirms this from the other direction. DNase destroys free DNA in the medium, so transformation would have been abolished. Conjugation is unaffected because the DNA travels through the mating bridge and is never exposed to the medium. Transduction is also DNase-resistant because the DNA is protected inside a capsid, but transduction was already excluded by experiment 2.
Transposition (option D) moves DNA between sites within one cell's genome; it cannot by itself move a gene from one strain to another.
The transfer is by conjugation (option A).
Option B is the tempting choice if you focus only on the fact that a plasmid is involved, but transformation is DNase-sensitive and does not need cell contact, so experiments 2 and 3 both rule it out.